A major shift has occurred in the strategic thinking of newly elected Democrats. Whereas in the first non-consecutive term of the Trump administration, Democrats were impeachment crazy. Now, despite their overwhelming victory in this year’s Midterm Elections, Democrats seem hesitant to pursue another impeachment.
Many Democrats believe that the president has committed impeachable offenses during his second non-consecutive term in office (and, by the way, there is far more evidence that he may have done that in his second term than at any time during his first term).

President Donald J. Trump holds a press conference at the 2026 NATO Summit, Wednesday, July 8, 2026, at the Bestepe Presidential Compound in Ankara, Turkey. (Official White House Photo by Daniel Torok)

President Donald J. Trump participates in a restricted bilateral meeting with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey, Tuesday, July 7, 2026, at the Bestepe Presidential Compound in Ankara, Turkey. (Official White House Photo by Daniel Torok)
Yet, a growing number of elected Democrats believe that an impeachment proceeding would both distract from their legislative agenda as well as paradoxically restore some semblance of support for Trump the way the first two impeachments did.
To be clear, there are some Democratic lawmakers who very much want to impeach Trump.
But there is a real split.
That debate highlights a fundamental tension within the Democratic Party. Sure, they won the election in overwhelming majorities.
But did they win the election because Americans are so desperate to see Trump impeached?
Or did Democrats win the election because the American people are fed up with the economic situation in the United States and the Iran War that President Trump started is the most unpopular conflict this country has fought?
A Tactical Decision
Democrats who understand that the 2026 Midterm Election was less a realignment election and more a dealignment election are reading the room correctly.
If they go in hard with impeachment, it will just tear apart whatever legislation the Democrats are planning to introduce.
If, however, in the conduct of the proper anti-corruption investigations the Democrats in Congress begin, they find actual evidence–not the pantomime they engaged in with Trump’s first two impeachments–and if Trump proves to be an obstructionist, then the Democrats might have the ability to initiate impeachment proceedings.
It all depends on what is going on at the time of impeachment.
Whereas in the first term, Americans were not ready to embrace impeachment for its own sake, and the Senate was nowhere near the number of votes needed to convict the president and remove him, the situation is different today.
Over the next two years, Democrats will have multiple opportunities to demonstrate how they are trying to legislate according to the will of the voter (such as ending the Iran War or pushing legislation that will address affordability).
If the forty-seventh president proves intransigent, as many believe he will, Trump’s already low approval ratings might go even lower.
At that point, the president would run the risk of alienating many members of the Senate–even what few members of his own party remain in power there in the new year.
Under those conditions, if the president is so unpopular that few would dare defend or support him, impeachment becomes a significant threat.
Despite his low approval ratings, the Democrats don’t currently have enough support from the people or the Senate to secure a conviction, which means impeachment would be both damaging to their legislative agenda and potentially galvanizing voters to forgive Trump.
Still, the Democrats would need 11 Republican senators to support Trump’s removal from office, assuming all senators participate and the Democratic caucus remains united.
That’s a tough order, especially if Democrats push for it from the start.
That’s why Democratic leaders debate when, how, or even whether to spend time and resources impeaching Trump rather than forcing him to veto legislation aimed at making the cost of living more affordable.
One Democratic strategist, Justin Snyder, explained why some Democrats are reticent to impeach Trump.
As those Democrats see it, Trump has been a gift to them as president: what other president could have delivered such sweeping Democratic victories in 2026?
Now, Trump becomes their prisoner in the White House for the next two years, where he will yell at the sky for that time, and rage-post on Truth Social, but he won’t be able to do much more than that.
Meanwhile, the Democrats will investigate the administration and stymie whatever policies Trump may have planned to enact–all while making him look worse than he already does in the eyes of the American voter.
Donald Trump is a Hostage No Matter What
Even without impeaching the president, the Democrats have such overwhelming majorities that they will significantly constrain the Trump administration’s ability to conduct policy.
Democrats will control committee agendas, possess subpoena authority, and exercise considerable influence over federal spending.
They will investigate corruption claims while scrutinizing unpopular military operations. Administration officials will be required to testify under oath (and if they refuse or if Trump takes his executive privilege too far, a constitutional crisis may erupt).
Interestingly, the White House issues explicit instructions on November 16 requiring all executive branch personnel to obtain administration approval before agreeing to testify before congressional committees.
There is a risk, though, that the president takes it too far, which could trigger the kind of impeachment scandal many Democrats are trying to avoid.
For now, though, it seems the Democrats will keep their impeachment powder dry. Democrats are keen on forcing Trump to either veto popular legislation or negotiate from a position of weakness on things like immigration.
About the Author: Brandon J. Weichert
Brandon J. Weichert is the Senior National Security Editor. He also manages The Weichert Brief on Substack. Weichert is the co-host of The Mario Nawfal Show on Twitter/X. He is the author of four bestselling national security books, most recently A Disaster of Our Own Making: How the West Lost Ukraine (Encounter Books). His next book, Fortress Americas: A New Monroe Doctrine (Tucker Carlson Books), is due out December 8. Follow him via Twitter/X @WeTheBrandon.
