Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Dollars and Sense

Trump Can’t Unsay the Words: He Admitted He Was Too Tough on Immigration and Now Says His Stance Is Unchanged

Democrats taking control of Congress plan sweeping changes to Donald Trump’s immigration policies, including defunding ICE and protections for Dreamers. Trump said in an interview that enforcement had been too tough, then said his stance was unchanged and made immigration hawk Stephen Miller his chief of staff, this analysis notes.

Donald Trump Speaking During 2024 White House Run
Donald Trump Speaking During 2024 White House Run. Creative Commons Photo.

Immigration has been a controversial topic in this country seemingly forever.

In 2016, it catapulted Donald J. Trump to the top of the Republican Party’s crowded presidential field.

Because of his extravagant and hawkish stances on immigration, Trump became the favorite of the GOP.

Trump promised to build a border wall separating the United States from Mexico–and to make Mexico pay for it all.

He vowed tougher immigration enforcement.

Of course, Trump couched it in very aggressive terms, and it generated much controversy.

But immigration enforcement and stern opposition to the kind of immigration policies that have defined the United States since the Reagan era were hallmarks of Trumpism.

A Seismic Shift

Things have fundamentally changed over the last year, since Trump returned to office for his second nonconsecutive term. Immigration remains a hot-button topic.

But not in a way that is amenable to President Trump or the GOP any longer; that’s because, while many Americans do support enforcing immigration laws, the way in which the Trump administration has enforced those laws–sending masked phalanxes of armed ICE agents into American cities–has proven to be unpopular.

So, too, have the methods by which illegal immigrants have been removed from the country.

Popular support for immigration enforcement remains high.

However, support for the Trump administration’s methods has proven to be fleeting–so much so that it became a net negative for Republican candidates in the most recent Midterms.

That is why the new Democratic majorities in the U.S. House of Representatives and U.S. Senate are preparing sweeping changes to the president’s immigration policies.

In fact, some Democrats think they have an opportunity to negotiate a bipartisan immigration reform package with the embattled 47th president.

The president himself admitted in a recent interview with Ross Douthat of 60 Minutes that his administration was too tough in terms of immigration enforcement and indicated a willingness to negotiate a lasting immigration deal with the incoming Democratic majorities (even if it included amnesty for immigrants who entered the country illegally).

To be fair to the president, one of his most consistent campaign promises appears to have been met.

He has significantly reduced illegal border crossings since returning to office last year.

Interestingly, prominent Democratic leaders, like Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ), believe that now is the time for a real immigration reform bill.

For Gallego, the argument from Republicans that no such deal could be enacted until illegal border crossings were greatly reduced has been taken off the table, thanks to the success of Trump’s immigration enforcement program.

Democrats are considering advancing the Dream and Promise Act, which would create pathways to permanent residency and eventual citizenship for eligible immigrants.

The Dreamers are proverbial low-hanging fruit, since they are the children of illegal immigrants.

In many cases, these children were either born and raised here or came to the United States at a very young age, and have no real connection to the countries their parents emigrated from.

Protections for Dreamers have historically had higher levels of public support than comprehensive immigration reform or other legalization programs covering the entire undocumented population.

Where Trump Will Land

The incoming Democratic Party wants protections for immigrants whose temporary legal status has been revoked, and they want to expand employment-based immigration opportunities.

Meanwhile, Democrats want to create policies that will address shortages in industries heavily dependent on immigrant workers.

These policy proposals interestingly align with the concerns of big businesses, notably agricultural producers and construction firms, who fear that the Trump administration’s mass deportations create economic dislocations for industries most dependent on immigrant workers.

Even as the president said he was willing to negotiate with Democrats on key legislation, notably immigration reform, he elevated his controversial immigration-hawk adviser, Stephen Miller, to White House Chief of Staff.

Miller was the principal architect of Trump’s restrictive immigration agenda since 2016.

Many now worry that the president intends to take on a more obstructionist role in the White House to force Democrats to back down from their harder-line stances.

Miller has long been an opponent of things like granting the Dreamers legalized status as citizens, and the incoming Democratic majorities suspect that he will encourage Trump’s darker instincts on the subject, negating any chance of cutting deals.

Plus, the remaining Conservative members of the GOP and the Republican Party’s base despise any compromise on illegal immigration.

More recently, Trump clarified his position on immigration policy, saying his stance remains unchanged (which differs from what he said in the recent 60 Minutes interview).

That, too, will complicate efforts to work with Democrats.

End to ICE?

Regardless of whether there will be comprehensive immigration reform or even reform involving the Dreamers, the fact is Democrats are committed to defunding ICE.

There are planned investigations into detention centers, federal immigration spending, officer training, and allegations of excessive force during enforcement operations.

Democrats might pursue legislation restricting certain enforcement practices and could even try to redirect federal resources away from mass deportation operations.

Republicans did secure multiyear funding for immigration enforcement, thereby limiting the Democrats’ ability to dismantle the administration’s deportation infrastructure immediately.

And Trump retains his veto authority. Nevertheless, one can expect fights over this area as Democrats assert more of their power in the new year.

About the Author: Brandon J. Weichert

Brandon J. Weichert is the Senior National Security Editor. He also manages The Weichert Brief on Substack. Weichert is the co-host of The Mario Nawfal Show on Twitter/X. He is the author of four bestselling national security books, most recently A Disaster of Our Own Making: How the West Lost Ukraine (Encounter Books). His next book, Fortress Americas: A New Monroe Doctrine (Tucker Carlson Books), is due out December 8. Follow him via Twitter/X @WeTheBrandon.

Brandon Weichert
Written By

Brandon J. Weichert is the Senior National Security Editor. He was previously the senior national security editor at The National Interest. Weichert is the host of The National Security Hour on iHeartRadio, where he discusses national security policy every Wednesday at 8 pm Eastern. He hosts a companion show on Rumble entitled "National Security Talk." Weichert consults regularly with various government institutions and private organizations on geopolitical issues. His writings have appeared in numerous publications, among them Popular Mechanics, National Review, MSN, and The American Spectator. And his books include Winning Space: How America Remains a Superpower, Biohacked: China's Race to Control Life, and The Shadow War: Iran's Quest for Supremacy. Weichert's newest book, A Disaster of Our Own Making: How the West Lost Ukraine, is available for purchase wherever books are sold. He can be followed on Twitter/X at @WeTheBrandon.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Military Hardware: Tanks, Bombers, Submarines and More

Key Points and Summary – NASA’s X-43A Hyper-X program was a tiny experimental aircraft built to answer a huge question: could scramjets really work...

Military Hardware: Tanks, Bombers, Submarines and More

Key Points and Summary – China’s J-20 “Mighty Dragon” stealth fighter has received a major upgrade that reportedly triples its radar’s detection range. -This...

Military Hardware: Tanks, Bombers, Submarines and More

Article Summary – The Kirov-class was born to hunt NATO carriers and shield Soviet submarines, using nuclear power, long-range missiles, and deep air-defense magazines...

Military Hardware: Tanks, Bombers, Submarines and More

Key Points and Summary – While China’s J-20, known as the “Mighty Dragon,” is its premier 5th-generation stealth fighter, a new analysis argues that...