Throughout the Trump era, the Democratic Party has been divided in ways that date back to the Hillary Clinton vs. Bernie Sanders nomination contest in 2016 and continued through Sanders’ challenge to the Democratic establishment four years later.
There are a few different varieties of the division, whether it’s liberal vs. leftist, or establishment vs. outsiders, and certain aspects of the divide have changed over time. The divide over Israel and Palestine, for instance, has become much more salient over the last decade.
Now, Democrats have won a major midterm election, riding widespread dissatisfaction with the second Trump presidency to major gains and control of both houses of Congress.
However, those divisions within the party are far from a thing of the past, even in victory. And they seem likely to continue, even after the midterms, with more to come heading into 2028.
A House (and Senate) Divided
According to a BBC analysis published this week, those divisions were apparent at a post-election conference in Denver called “What’s Next: investigating strategies and priorities for the future of the Democratic Party.”
One example was James Talarico, who pulled off a historic victory in the Texas Senate race, speaking at the conference.
He was cheered when he first got on stage, but the audience was less enthusiastic when the incoming senator talked about working with Republicans.
“We should make the final two years of his presidency the most productive of any presidency in American history,” Talarico said at the event.
The BBC reported that while the atmosphere in Denver was jubilant, signs of a divide emerged within the new Democratic majority.
There were also signs of disagreement over whether Democrats should directly investigate and confront the Trump Administration or focus on policy priorities and delivering for the people who voted for them.
Some on the left side of the party, such as Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and incoming Michigan Senator Abdul El-Sayed, also did not attend the event in Denver.
This week, Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) proposed legislation that includes abolishing ICE and instituting reparations for slavery.
“We need to show people what Democrats can do with our majority. Reparations. Abortion justice. Medicare for All. Abolishing ICE. Childcare. Paid leave. And more,” the Congresswoman said in a social media post, although it doesn’t appear that this specific agenda has buy-in from the incoming Democratic leadership.
A Senate Contest
This week, the House Democratic caucus chose Hakeem Jeffries, with little dissent and no major challenge, as their designate for Speaker of the House, making him the first Black lawmaker to take that position; Jeffries will officially become Speaker when the whole House votes in January.
In part because of their large majority, Democrats avoided the conflagration Republicans faced when they took the House in 2022, when it took dozens of ballots to elect Kevin McCarthy Speaker.
He was forced out by the end of the year anyway.
However, the leadership battle in the Senate is more contested, with Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) challenging Sen. Chuck Schumer, who has led the Democratic caucus as both majority and minority leader throughout the Trump era.
The caucus will vote on December 1 and, per The New York Times, of the 56 incoming Democratic senators, 16 have backed Schumer, 5 support Van Hollen, and 5 have “called for change” but not specifically backed the challenger.
That leaves 29 senators who have not announced who they support.
One senator, John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, has vowed to leave the Democratic caucus if Van Hollen becomes majority leader.
As noted by CNN, the battle is in part a proxy fight over Israel, with Schumer seen as a strong supporter of the U.S./Israel relationship, and Van Hollen less of one.
It’s also something of a generational battle, although the 67-year-old Van Hollen is less than a decade younger than the 75-year-old Schumer.
Schumer is considered the favorite, but as The New Republic said in an analysis, the result is not yet certain, especially considering how many new members the caucus is about to add.
“The new people will take significant cues from what Ossoff and Warnock decide to do,” one source close to the Van Hollen side told the outlet, referring to the two popular Democratic senators from Georgia. “Either could run for president, so people are paying more attention to them.”
About the Author: Stephen Silver
Stephen Silver is an award-winning journalist, essayist, and film critic, and contributor to the Philadelphia Inquirer, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Broad Street Review, and Splice Today. The co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle, Stephen lives in suburban Philadelphia with his wife and two sons. For over a decade, Stephen has written thousands of articles on politics, national security, technology, and the economy. Follow him on X (formerly Twitter) at @StephenSilver, and subscribe to his Substack newsletter.
